Thursday, July 14, 2011

Federal Subsidies For College Is A Scam

I decided that rather than just coming up with a list of federal government programs that could be cut or eliminated, which is a valuable exercise in itself, I would instead pinpoint a few areas where the U.S. government overspends and illustrate the negative aspects of these spending policies. The first one I'll tackle is the arena of federal expenditures on student financial aid beyond high school. In 2011, the federal government will spend $42 billion (that's 42,000,000,000 dollars!) on Student Financial Assistance. The lion's share of this money goes to Pell Grants, which subsidizes student loans at low interest rates. Some of this money goes to direct assistance to defray tuition costs for low-income students. And, of course, a decent chunk of this mound of cash goes to the bureaucracy needed to run the program.

Let me start with the most obvious critique of this program, which is the same with most federal programs: THIS IS NOT THE ROLE OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. Unless someone has rendered a valuable service to our nation, such as serving in the armed services, the national treasury should not act as a piggy bank to help people afford college loans. By doing so, the federal government is acting in its typically redistributive mode, taking money from taxpayers who decide not to go to college, and giving it to those who do. Why should a hard-working plumber, electrician, construction worker, or landscaper be forced to fund other people's higher education when they have chosen to forego college themselves? Also, college graduates, on average, earn a great deal more money over a lifetime than those who do not attend college. By taking money paid by non-college-goers to fund the education of those who choose to pursue higher education, we are engaging in a redistributive measure of the most illogical kind, from those who have less to those who will most likely have more.

More importantly, however, federal subsidies of student loans act to skew the market price of higher education in a steeply more expensive direction. Whenever additional money is made available to purchase a product of limited supply, such as medical care, or, in our example, higher education, the price of that product, as a rule of economics, will rise. In fact, the college inflation rate has ranged from 1.47 to 2.01 times the rate of general inflation from 1958 through 2008.








Source of Table: http://montana.collegesavings.com/montana/pdf/inflation_table.pdf















Source of both graphs: http://www.finaid.org/savings/tuition-inflation.phtml



These increases in college tuition are made possible (and inevitable) by the flow of federal money into the coffers of our nation's institutions of higher learning. Some may argue that the high cost of a college education necessitates government subsidies. The truth of the matter, however, is that these very subsidies have created the college tuition monster, and at taxpayer expense.

If colleges had to compete in a fair and free market for the dollars of prospective students, with no government money to skew the market, the price of a college education would drop and stabilize. And it would save $42 billion this year, or 2.6% of our current federal deficit!




- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad


Location:Panera McHenry

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

National Debt Crisis, Part 1

As a nation, the United States is quickly spinning toward debt Armageddon. Our national debt is currently somewhere north of $14 trillion - that's 14,000,000,000,000 dollars. Even more portending of fiscal doom is the percentage of U.S. Gross Domestic Product (GDP) this represents. As of 2010, our debt stands at about 92% of GDP, if all foreign and domestic debt is included. To put this in terms that are easier to grasp, imagine a household with an annual income of $100,000 that has accumulated a credit card bill of $92,000. Such a situation would require immediate and significant change to avoid financial collapse.

How do we, as a nation, address this crisis? Somehow, we need to get federal spending to match, and eventually fall below, revenues coming in to the federal treasury. But projected budgets for the next 5 years show annual deficits that will increase our debt to over $20 trillion, which will most likely increase debt to GDP to over 105%. In other words, far from beginning to balance our budget and pay off our debt, we are significantly increasing it. And this at a time when spending on Social Security and Medicare will be skyrocketing as the disproportionately large Baby Boomer generation begins to retire.

Clearly, we are heading into a financial abyss that is currently swallowing some Western European nations, such as Greece and Portugal. One only needs to turn on the news to see the recent violent repercussions of such a debt-induced crisis in Greece. So how do we avoid the inevitable coming crisis that our current fiscal policies have wrought? I will be addressing this from 2 perspectives in upcoming entries: from the revenue side, and from the spending side.

- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad

Location:Panera Bread, McHenry, Illinois

Thursday, June 3, 2010

Anti-Semitism Alive and Well

I have to give Adolf Hitler credit for one thing: no one can claim he wasn't clear about his feelings toward Jews. Hitler made it clear that he wanted Jews wiped off the planet, and was willing to do his part in accomplishing this. Unfortunately, anti-semitism did not begin or end with Hitler. There is still a good chunk of humanity that blames Jews, and often the nation of Israel, for many of the evils in today's world. Some, like the murderers of Hezbollah, Hamas, and al-Qaeda, and the current president of Iran, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, are, like Hitler, quite clear about their rabid hatred for Jews and Israel. But, sadly, there is a pervasive prejudice against Jews and Israel found among many nations, organizations, and individuals who purport to be fair and who claim to want peace and justice in the world.

Take the United Nations. This body is supposed to be an impartial arbiter between the different nations and people groups of the world. Yet in the 62 year history of the modern nation of Israel, the UN has passed over 65 resolutions against the nation of Israel and NONE against the Palestinians and Arabs who oppose Israel's existence. Israel is a democracy which grants basic human and civil rights to its citizens, whether Jewish or not. Israel respects the rights of women, minorities, gays, religious people, secular people, blacks, Arabs, and others who live within its borders. By contrast, all of Israel's neighbors, along with the Hamas-led Palestinians in Gaza, do not recognize similar rights for women, gays, non-Muslims, and people who recognize Israel's right to exist. Over and over again, representatives of Hamas, Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad, the PLO, and other terrorist groups, have killed and maimed innocent Israeli civilians. None of these groups recognize Israel's right to exist, and clearly express their desire to see the Jewish nation destroyed. Yet it is Israel who has consistently borne the brunt of UN condemnation for actions taken to defend its people, not the groups who seek Israel's destruction.


In fact, of the world's 195 countries, there is only 1 whose right to exist is questioned at all, and that nation is Israel. Is it a coincidence that the only nation on earth whose very existence is daily questioned and threatened is a nation established for the Jewish people? Shortly after taking power in Iran, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said that Israel should be "wiped out from the map." He added, "And God willing, with the force of God behind it, we shall soon experience a world without the United States and Zionism." Compare these statements with the one made by Hitler in a speech delivered to the Reichstag shortly before World War 2 began. In Hitler's speech of January 30, 1939, he said:

Today I want to be a prophet once more: if international finance Jewry inside and outside of Europe should succeed once more in plunging nations into another world war, theconsequence will not be the Bolshevization of the earth and thereby the victory of Jewry, but the annihilation of the Jewish race in Europe.

Sadly, the world stood by and watched Hitler and his Nazi thugs murder 6 millions Jews before they were stopped. As a result, Jews and those who support them should take seriously threats made by the likes of Hitler to try to wipe Jews out. Where is the UN's and the world's condemnation for Ahmadinejad for his threats to wipe out Israel? Where is the outrage at his desire to see the United States, the best friend of the Jewish nation and people, and the greatest force for good on earth, destroyed? Why is the United Nations idly watching Iran equip itself with the capability to build and deliver nuclear weapons that can bring massive death and destruction to Israel? It is time for good people, Jewish and Gentile, to stand up to the evil of anti-semitism. Failure to do so is cowardice and is itself evil. Israel, unlike the Jews in Europe under Hitler, thankfully has the power to do a lot of damage to her enemies. The good nations and people around the world, especially free democracies like the U.S., need to stand with Israel and the Jewish people against the evil that would love to repeat the Nazi genocide of the Holocaust.



Location:Illinois 60,Volo,United States

Sunday, May 2, 2010

Arizona Anti-Illegal Immigration Law: Right Wing Hate?

Laying in bed this morning listening to the radio, I heard a young Chicago man describe how he was carried across the border from Mexico to the United States when he was 6 months old, and he has never been back to Mexico in his life. He feels Chicago is his home, the U.S. is his country. He then dismissed anyone who wants to see him returned to Mexico as an illegal immigrant as "a racist right-winger." Of course, the recent Arizona anti-illegal immigration law prompted the interview in which these comments were made.

I have no desire to see this man deported to Mexico...none. His entry into the U.S. was not his choice, and this is his home. It is his classification of anyone who wants to stop illegal immigration as racist that I find to be objectionable. This is a common tactic of my fellow Americans on the left: to dismiss anyone with a differing point of view or more conservative outlook as racist, xenophobic, homophobic, sexist, intolerant, Islamophobic, or bigoted. (Dennis Prager points this out on a regular basis on his radio talk show...credit for this list must go to him!!!). Rather than actually try to argue the issues on their merits, progressives will almost automatically resort to charging their opponents with one of these labels. After all, racists don't need to be argued with; they simply need to be rebuked and ignored. This is a very convenient way of not having to come up with a logical argument to support one's viewpoint...simply end the argument by labeling the enemy as a hater, and you've won.

My personal point of view is that the new Arizona law is flawed: it has some good points and bad points, like most human-generated laws, but overall, it could have been more effectively drafted. My point is not to defend the law. But the charge that the 51% of Americans who support the law (Gallup Poll, April 29, 2010), including 70% of Arizonans, are all right-wing racists, is a vile slander and reflects an inability to formulate a cogent argument against the law. Racism has NOTHING to do with support for this bill...and those who disagree with the law should stop charging those who disagree with them with it. Instead, come up with some ideas that reflect your point of view, and express them in a civil way. Yeah, it requires more thought and hard work...hopefully, that's not too strong a deterrent.

Saturday, March 20, 2010

Opportunity

Webster's dictionary defines opportunity as "a good chance for advancement or progress." Ever since its inception in 1776, and especially following the adoption of the U.S. Constitution in 1788 and the Bill of Rights in 1791, the United States has been distinctly viewed on the world stage as a land of opportunity. Why is that? I am quite sure that one factor, more than any other, has led to America's reputation as a land of abundant opportunity: LIMITED GOVERNMENT.

So why is limited government a vital and necessary ingredient for opportunity to blossom and thrive? Quite simply, opportunity thrives where human beings have the ability to make choices that will allow them to advance, without interference or obstruction from others. By its very nature, government exists to obstruct. This is quite appropriate when the government obstructs killers, thieves, vandals, and drunk drivers from violating the God-given rights of others to their lives, liberty, and property. When the government acts to protect and secure the rights of its citizens by obstructing those who would violate those rights, it is doing what it was made to do. But when government does almost anything else, it is obstructing those same citizens from realizing opportunities they could otherwise pursue.

Take taxes...the government certainly does. Every dollar the government takes from its citizens in taxes results in slightly less opportunity for those citizens. Or consider government regulation of wages - when the government decides to require a business to pay its workers $1 more per hour, the opportunity to hire one more worker may be erased. That's an opportunity lost for both the boss and the potential employee. Now, no sane person argues that there should be a total elimination of taxes or a total abdication of government regulation in the workplace. But it must be recognized that every governmental exercise of power is a limitation on its citizens' choices, and that is an opportunity killer.

America is distinct in the world today because of the carefully constructed limitations on the size, reach, and power of government in our lives. The founders of this nation created such a system by ingenious design...and it has resulted in the greatest land of opportunity the world has yet seen. It is my earnest hope that we do not now wreck what the Founding Fathers so carefully constructed.


Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Opportunity, Individualism, and Liberty.

I've been doing a lot of thinking about the meaning of the United States of America over the course of the past 16 months, ever since the election of President Obama. I respectfully disagree with the President on many more issues than I agree with him, and many of these disagreements warrant their own discussions. But I think I've discovered that, at their core, my differences with the President stem from philosophies of government that are diametrically opposed to one another. It seems like great ideas often come down to "sets of 3," and I've isolated 3 concepts that form the core of my philosophy of government: opportunity, individualism, and liberty. I plan on exploring each of these 3 ideals over the course of the coming weeks. In my opinion, they form, and have always formed, the foundation upon which our nation was founded; and it is through these virtues that the United States has become the greatest nation the world has ever seen.

Friday, August 7, 2009

Saddam Hussein...Good Riddance!

Our last president, George W. Bush, is one of my heroes. His Vice-President, Dick Cheney, is someone I admire greatly. Don Rumsfeld didn't do a very good job during his last couple of years as Secretary of Defense, but his mistakes were tactical, not moral, and I admire his service to our country. In the eyes of many liberals, these admissions of who I admire, unfortunately, are tantamount to admitting hero-worship of the upper echelon of Nazi Germany. But if one can look beyond one's own BDS (Bush Derangement Syndrome), I believe it becomes apparent that many of President Bush's decisions and actions showed a rare and heroic courage and brand of leadership rarely shown among politicians.

To understand why I consider President Bush's decision to intervene in Iraq heroic, I need to review some facts about the man dethroned as a result of U.S. action: Saddam Hussein. Unlike President Bush, Saddam Hussein is rightly and fairly compared to Adolf Hitler. Both Hitler and Hussein engaged in mass murder, political repression, terror, torture, unprovoked acts of war against neighboring and non-neighboring countries, antisemitism, manipulation of the diplomatic overtures of other nations, the breaking of agreements with other countries, and other horrible evils. Both precipitated long wars that decimated their neighbors and their own populations. Both men were exceedingly self-centered, power-hungry, and cruel, and they needed to be stopped. And in both cases, the United States played a big part in doing the stopping. For that, I am proud to be an American.

Saddam Hussein's brand of torture was particularly heinous and cruel. Here are a few examples of methods of torture regularly used by Hussein's thugs to extract confessions from enemies and to punish those who dared to oppose him:
  • Gouging out of victims' eyes.
  • Piercing of hands with electric drills. In one documented case, acid was poured in the open wounds.
  • Hanging victims by their wrists and then lowering them into acid baths. This method was used frequently during the Iraqi invasion and occupation of Kuwait in 1990 and 1991.
  • Nailing victims' tongues to wooden boards.
  • Raping women while forcing their husbands or fathers to watch the rapes.
  • Using bees and scorpions to attack and sting young, naked children in front of their parents.
  • Pouring of boiling water into victims' rectums.
  • Using hot irons and blow torches to burn victims.
Of course, Saddam has long been known for his use of chemical weapons against Iranian soldiers in the long Iran-Iraq war in the 1980's, as well as against Kurdish citizens of Iraq. And, tragically, there are the mass graves discovered in a multitude of locations in Iraq, a testimony to Hussein's 25 year reign of terror and mass murder in Iraq.

I believe that the U.S. had good reason to go into Iraq and remove Saddam Hussein from power in 2003. In order to keep power after his expulsion from Kuwait in 1991, Hussein agreed to a series of limitations, sanctions, and inspections, agreements which he broke in 17 distinct ways over the next decade. Each of these breaches came with the understanding that they would end the cease fire of 1991 and result in new hostilities against Hussein. Saddam also failed to comply with the program set up to destroy his weapons of mass destruction. We all know that the stockpiles of WMDs in Iraq were not found in the amounts we expected. However, the intelligence agencies of literally dozens of countries were all convinced that these programs had not been terminated, and that Saddam had certainly not allowed verification of the destruction of these weapons, as agreed upon in the 1991 cease fire agreement. Even Saddam's own generals were fooled by Hussein into believing that the WMD program was a greater reality than it turned out to be.

My bottom line, however, is that Hussein needed to be removed from power because he was a great force of evil and cruelty whose continued position of power meant continuing suffering for the people of Iraq. The U.S. had the power and opportunity to rid Iraq and the world of this great evil; not to do so would have been wrong. I know that some question the right of the United States to get involved in other countries' affairs, even when great evil can be stopped by our intervention. But if we had failed to act based on the notion that it was simply "none of our business," then a man of unspeakable cruelty would have continued to destroy innocent lives. I believe that the power to stop cruelty and evil comes with the responsibility to actually act on that power. President Bush and his administration saw this and acted. The world is a better place without Saddam Hussein breathing its air. Thank you, President Bush.